CARE OR CONTROL - NOT GUILTY OF OPERATE OVER 80 BUT GUILTY OF CARE OR CONTROL OVER 80
Saturday, November 18, 2017 at 7:10PM
MapleBookPublications

This case is an excellent review of the elements of the offence of being in care or control of a motor vehicle while over 80.  At trial Mr. Pawluk was acquitted of impaired operation of a motor vehicle and operation while over 80. On appeal the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld the acquittals on the "operation" counts but substituted a verdict of guilty for the included offence of having "care or control" of a motor vehicle while over 80:

The law alerts an accused to their jeopardy for included offences, and in this case, questions were asked of [the officer] that could only be relevant to the issue of Mr. Pawluk’s care or control. It should not have come as a surprise when the Crown sought a care or control over 80 conviction. R. v. Pawluk, 2017 ONCA 863

Article originally appeared on Investigating Impaired Drivers (https://www.lawprofessionalguides.com/).
See website for complete article licensing information.